
We are independent insurance agents in Centerville Ohio. Fay Insurance offers the best insurance companies for you and your family throughout Ohio. Our staff is on a mission to help you develop the right coverage to meet your insurance needs. Through dedication, knowledge, and a tireless work ethic, we will be the local Centerville Ohio insurance agency that our customers want to send their friends and families to.
With the complicated nature of insurance and the importance of things that are most precious to you, you cannot afford to have an agent at an 800 number or an offshore call center try to ensure you understand your needs. Trust our local Centerville team of insurance experts to sit down with you in our office or at your dining room table to listen to you, develop a plan, and provide you with the products that will make you bulletproof in the face of life’s unexpected events.
Insurance To Protect Your Family and Business
We have a stable of well-known Insurance companies that we can use to protect the things that mean the most to you, your life, your home, your business, and your vehicles.
Personal Insurance
Business Insurance
- Business Owners Policy (BOP)
- General Liability
- Commercial Auto
- Workers Compensation
- Bonds
- Commercial Property
- Specialty Contractors Insurance
- Cyber Liability
Insurance Can Change Lives
Enjoy the Fay Insurance Agency Blog. Our team of independent insurance agents in Centerville Ohio want to share with you up-to-date information and personal accounts of how insurance can change lives, along with financial information and trends that allow you to put it all into perspective.
- Life insurance for Business Partnership Buyout
- Preparing for Holiday Trips
- Do I need Business Insurance if I Work from Home?
- Veteran & Military Recognition and Beneficiaries
- 10 Tips For A Secure Trick or Treat
- Understanding Group Home Insurance with Greg Fay Insurance
Independent Insurance Agents in Centerville Ohio

Family-Owned, Veteran-Owned, Independent Insurance agents in Centerville Ohio, Northwood Ohio, and West Chester Ohio. Stop paying too much for quality insurance.
We are a small team of professional insurance agents that are active in our communities and know our clients as friends. Are you keeping local insurance agents that work actively on keeping you protected? Schedule a meeting today to explore your competitively priced insurance options. Have an insurance claim? We have insurance carriers listed for easy access.


















Greg Fay Insurance Agency – Google Reviews
Thank you for trusting our local team of insurance agents in Centerville Ohio with your insurance needs. We would appreciate you taking a moment to write a Google Review to help us grow.
![]()
![]()
BerbFebruary 10, 2025
Great communication. Personally reaches out with updates or rate changes. Highly recommend.![]()
Jared MitchellFebruary 10, 2025
We have been with Greg Fay for years and they have done a great job with finding us affordable insurance that meets our specific needs as well as very rapid and thorough communication. Highly recommend them!![]()
MikeJanuary 26, 2025
Great people and professional as well. Very quick to respond to any questions or changes. I have not had to use them for a claim yet so no experience there. Otherwise would not hesitant to recommend.![]()
Kristi SmithJanuary 25, 2025
Can I just say how REFRESHING it is to deal with a company who RESPONDS SO QUICKLY and FOLLOWS THROUGH ON WHAT THEY SAY they will do?! It can be such a HASSLE dealing with companies today with so many HOOPS to jump through, long holds on the phone, and transfers to other departments?! Greg Fay Insurance Agency is different. Their customer service is unparalleled!!! They are in a class all their own!! Greg Fay Insurance Agency stands head and shoulders about the competition... actually they have no real competition! They are a DREAM to work with!!![]()
Bob FosterJanuary 10, 2025
Great folks to deal with and have on your side.![]()
Carrie HaraszDecember 10, 2024
We had some major issues with another agent that we had been with for 5+ years. We needed to change insurance companies and make updates with our home insurance. I had called because their office was the only one open the day I saw searching, and we couldn’t be happier with how everything was done. Greg took his time to explain every detail of what was going to happen and connected with us every step of the way. Every question I had, he had an answer for. He worked out things between the companies and helped us when we really needed it