We provide insurance protection for you and your family in the Centerville and South Dayton area as well as throughout the State of Ohio. Our staff is on a mission to help you develop the right coverage to meet your insurance needs. Through dedication, knowledge, and a tireless work ethic, we will be the local Centerville Ohio insurance agency that our customers want to send their friends and families to.

With the complicated nature of insurance and the importance of things that are most precious to you, you cannot afford to have an agent at an 800 number or an offshore call center try to insure understand your needs. Trust our local Centerville team of insurance experts to sit down with you in our office or at your dining room table to listen to you, develop a plan and provide you with the products that will make you bullet-proof in the face of life’s unexpected events.

We Protect Your Family and Business

We have a stable of well-known Insurance companies that we can use to protect the things that mean the most to you, your life, your home, your business and your vehicles.

Property and Casualty

Business Insurance

Independent Insurance Agents

Family-Owned, Veteran-Owned, Independent Insurance agents in Centerville Ohio, Northwood Ohio, and West Chester Ohio. Stop paying too much for quality insurance. We are a small team of professional insurance agents that are active in our communities and know our clients as friends. Are you keeping local insurance agents that work actively on keeping you protected? Schedule a meeting today to explore your competitively priced insurance options. Have an insurance claim? We have insurance carriers listed for easy access.

Google Reviews

Thank you for trusting our local team of insurance agents near Dayton Ohio insurance office with your insurance needs. We would appreciate you taking a moment to write a Google Review to help us grow.

      
   Greg Fay Insurance
   136 Google reviews 
  Write a review 
  
 
 
   
 
 
        
   Jeff H. 
 April 15, 2024.
 
 
  I have worked with Charlie Drain and his group for three years. He and his team are a pleasure to work with. Regardless, each year I ask other agents to quote. Let’s be honest, I want the lowest cost and highest protection. However, each and every year Charlie’s quotes are lower than all the others, without sacrificing coverage quantity or quality.
  
 
       
   Keith 
 April 10, 2024.
 
 
  Great service. Charlie Drain was especially helpful in getting our insurance policy set up on our new home and cancelling our insurance policy on our existing home.
  
 
       
   Michelle Pierce-Mobley 
 March 28, 2024.
 
 
  Greg Fay and company are my family's trusted insurance advisors.  Greg has done an outstanding job providing the coverages needed for our family.  He is timely, and responds quickly to policy questions.  He is proactive with renewals, always shopping for the best value without having to be prompted.  I would highly recommend Greg Fay Insurance.
  
 
       
   David Machowsky 
 March 28, 2024.
 
 
  
  
 
       
   Hanna Fisher 
 March 25, 2024.
 
 
  
  
 
       
   Brandi O'Neal 
 March 14, 2024.
 
 
  They got me additional coverage and a better rate! Very friendly and quick to get things finalized. Great team here.
  
 
       
   Todd Tobe 
 March 14, 2024.
 
 
  Greg is one of the best leaders and men that I know.  He and his team do a fantastic job in getting the correct product and coverage for your needs at a great price.  Give them a call.

Being a Veteran Owned Agency is also a big plus for me.  My Dad served in the Army, and my son is currently serving our country with the Air Force.
  
 
       
   Art Barnette 
 February 23, 2024.
 
 
  Great service, honest people to deal with
  
 
       
   Jon Bucher 
 February 20, 2024.
 
 
  
  
 
       
   Norma Westbrock 
 February 15, 2024.